Wrestling Autographs

by Tom Vasko
(Franklin, VA)

Nature Boy Buddy Rogers Autograph

Nature Boy Buddy Rogers Autograph

My mom was a die-hard wrestling fan in the early fifties and was a regular at the wrestling matches in Cleveland, OH. Several of her poems were featured in the magazine ... Wrestling As You Like It.

She wrote to NY promoter Bill Johnston so many times that they were on first name basis.(LOL) Anyway, we were cleaning our family estate when I found her autograph book, which I had been searching for for several years.

The book has all of the GREAT wrestlers from her generation and some other celebrities, including Cleveland Indians baseball players. The wrestlers are... Gorgeous George, Nature Boy Buddy Rogers, Luther Lindsey, Bill Miller, Don Eagle and many that I haven't determined yet.

I could not find a Buddy Rogers or Gorgeous George on eBay. I want to sell the collection, but, because it's mixed with other autographs, should I sell them one at a time or as a whole collection? I sell sports autographs on eBay, but I'm not sure how to do this. Your opinion is appreciated. On the Gorgeous George, she has the bobby pin with the autograph. She always sat in the front row.

Tom Vasko
tv1vasko@verizon.net


Wrestling Autographs on eBay

Comments for
Wrestling Autographs

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Mar 16, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		1950's Wrestling Autographs
by: Bill

I really like old autograph books like the one you have. Often, valuable autographs are found in them. Since most of them don't have photos, some of those valuable autographs are never identified because the owner can't figure out who signed them.

It sound like you are having trouble identifying some of the autographs. eBay is probably the best place to sell your autographs and identify the "unknowns" at the same time. List the autographs as "1950's Wrestling Autographs" (add "with Gorgeous George" if there is room). Collectors will find them and most likely recognize the signatures.

The names that you mentioned are some of the biggest wrestling stars of the 1950's. Gorgeous George was the biggest name in pro wrestling for a few years. Practically everybody who bought TVs when they first came on the market watched wrestling, and Gorgeous George was a household name. By the time Buddy Rogers became "Nature Boy," he was one of the top three or four biggest names in wrestling.

Don Eagle was the most popular Indian star of his time, and really no other legitimate (he was a Mohawk from Quebec) Native American wrestler to this day has been as popular as he was. His image was used to market all kinds of trinkets and toys.

Luther Lindsey was one of the most popular African American wrestlers of that era. He was often billed as "Colored Champion" or some variation, and he was one of the first African Americans to work matches against whites. He worked many times against NWA World Champion Lou Thesz. Lindsey had legit wrestling skills, in addition to being a great showman. He was billed under both the names "Lindsay" and "Lindsey."

Usually autograph books have more than one name on the same page or "front and back." This makes it hard to separate the autographs to sell them indvidually. If an autograph is rare and valuable, sometimes it makes since to target that autograph with scissors and harm or destroy other less valuable autographs. But with wrestling autographs this is seldom the case. The entire book is usually worth more and is easier to sell than clipped signatures.

Gorgeous George called the bobby pins that he threw to the crowd "Georgie Pins." Not very many have survived to this day. With a signature the bobby pin should be worth $50 - $75.

The Don Eagle and Buddy Rogers autographs should be worth around $20 each. Luther Lindsay might bring $10. These are best case scenarios. Autographs on photos are more valuable and easier to sell.

If it were my book, I would sell it in one listing and start the bidding at a figure where I would be comfortable letting it go. Include scans of as many autographs as you can.



Mar 17, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		AUTOGRAPH LISTING
by: Anonymous

Thank You! The auction is up now. Can you go on e-bay and see what you think. What do you feel a FAIR price would be? Remember, there are 13 1950 Cleveland Indians and some movie stars. Your opinion is appreciated.

Tom
Mar 17, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Wrestling Autographs
by: Bill

How do you have the auction listed? I can't find it.
Mar 18, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Wrestling autographs
by: Tom

Hi Bill,

You can just stay on this site and click on wrestling autographs on e-bay.

Tom
Mar 18, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Wrestling Autographs
by: Bill

You have a nice book, but I don't think you will get anywhere near $995 for it, especially not in the today's economy. If you'd rather keep it than let it go for anything less than that, that's understandable. It might even be a good idea to keep it for a better price in the future.

It is possible that you have some names that are worth more than some of the ones you listed. I saw "Eddie Cantor" above the Argentina Rocca that usually retails at $50.
Mar 18, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		WRESTLING AUTOGRAPHS
by: BY TOM

Thanks Bill!

Here I thought that wasn't enough. I am getting a lot of interest and quite a few e-mails. Some one who paid $203.00 for an autographed photo of Gorgeous George wanted me to sell that one separately with the georgie pin. I tried to put the names of all the ones that I thought would get everyones attention but some I just don't know. Could I e-mail you some of the names I left off and maybe you could tell me if they should be listed? Another thing, should I remove baseball and change to entertainment. I definitely want to keep wrestling. Your pretty good at this and your help is appreciated. Thanks again,

Tom
Mar 18, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Wrestling Autographs
by: Bill

Let me have the names and I will tell you if they are worth mentioning.

I knew that you would get a lot of interest. I just think $1000 is going to be pushing the envelope on an eBay auction, with primarily wrestling autographs. You might get offers.

That is a nice Cleveland Indian page, but the wrestling collectors aren't going to care about it. That might be one that you want to try to sell separately if you can separate it from the album without hurting any others.

Btw, you misspelled Rocca as Rocco.
Mar 18, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		More Names
by: By Tom

Here you go Bill and thanks for taking so much time.
Jim Grange #12, David Rogers, Jim Malone, Yukon Eric, Wild Bill ??, Angela Trindade, W. Kowalski,? Preece, Bill Johnston, Frances Bolten, Toni Spauding, Bill Callahan, Dane Clark, Ace Rose, Curt Massey, Jess Barker, Ivan Bull, Delmars Franklin, Joe Scarpello, Jill Warren, Fran Kip Laine & Red Haley! Some of the spelling may be off but do your best. Thanks again,

Tom
Mar 19, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Autographs
by: Anonymous

Joe Scarpello was a pro wrestler. He had a career that lasted the better part of three decades. Scarpello is a $10 autograph.

Yukon Eric was one of the biggest names in wrestling in the 1940s and 1950s. He was a huge draw, very colorful. He did a Canadian lumberman gimmick that was pretty close to the personality of the real man (Eric Holmback). He lost an ear during a botched worked wrestling move. The guy who took his ear off was Wladek Kowalski (the W. Kowalski that you have). Yukon Eric died at around 40 years old. He was always a loner, and he became despondent after a divorce - then committed suicide. Yukon Eric's autograph is worth between $25 - $50.

After taking off Eric's ear, Kowalaski became an even bigger heel and began calling himself "Killer" Kowalski. He was a top wrestler from the 1950s to the late 1970s. After retiring, he opened a wrestling school. One of his students was the WWE's Triple H. His autograph is worth $10 - $15.

"Wild Bill" could be Wild Bill Longson. He won the NWA World Wrestling Championship three times in the 1940s. The NWA Title was the most prestigious title in wrestling in that era. Of course it was awarded, not won - but it was certainly the biggest honor in wrestling. His autograph is worth $20 - $40. Since he worked heel most of his career, he didn't sign many autographs at the matches.

Fran Kip Laine - Maybe Frankie Laine? The voice behind "Rawhide."

That's all I recognize.


Mar 19, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Thanks for identifying
by: Anonymous

WoW!

Thanks again. It sounds like Yukon Eric had a sad ending just like Don Eagle. I knew Killer Kowalski, but didn't realize it was the same one as her autograph. I was a BIG wrestling fan in the 70's and some of the wrestlers from that generation made it to mine like Johnny Valentine and some others. It was the mid atlantic wrestling.
Nov 15, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Collection of over 200 Autographs
by: Anonymous

Hello,
I appreciate your comments about the different pro wrestling autographs. I have over 200 of them from the 50's and 60's. I also have several copies of the wrestling mag "As You Like It" along with some photos and referral letters that came through the president of each wrestler's fan club. Does anyone have an opinion on how I proceed to offer this for sale? What it might be worth? Thanks Big. Terry.

_______Answer:

I have found that eBay is the best place to sell wrestling autographs. Vintage wrestling memorabilia is a narrow niche. The number of people who collect it is small, but they are always looking for items that they don't have. They all hang out on eBay. Most wrestling autographs are inexpensive, less than $25 each. But some can get pricey. If you have Primo Carnera, for example, a dealer would list it for $150+. The most valuable wrestling autographs are those where the person was more famous in some other profession. Joe Louis, Max Baer and Jack Dempsey dabbled in wrestling. Louis and Baer signatures are worth $150, dealer pricing. Dempsey is worth $75. Some lucky people find Jim Thorpe in old autograph albums and wrestling photo books. (He was a manager, but only for show) Those would be worth more than $1000.

Bill
Nov 15, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		RE AUTO'S
by: Tom

Hi Terry,

I took Bill's advice and ended up selling my autographs on E-bay with separate auctions instead of as a whole. I believe I got $240.00 for Gorgeous George With the bobbie pin, and the others went anywhere from $10.00 to $45.00 like Bill said they would. I want to say Buddy Rogers and Don Eagle were the next best two. Good luck! And Bill, if you're still out there, I have a few more I didn't list because I wasn't sure who they were. Can you help identify these? Thanks,

Tom

P.S. How do I download autographs ???
Nov 15, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		eBay Autographs
by: Tom

Tom, you got a good price for Gorgeous George pin and autograph. What probably helped you was a good description that attracted more bidders. Georgie pins are rare.

If you want me to look at the other autographs, start another thread. You can post four photos now.

Thanks for your comment. I like hearing the results of eBay auctions.

Nov 16, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Thanks for the Comments
by: Anonymous

Thanks Fellas,

I think I need to take a closer look at who I have. I have not had the time to go through each one. Don't really know what I have here. I'm sure I'll have a report for you all when I get this all out on the kitchen table. Thanks! -Terry.
Dec 07, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Wrestling Archive Complete
by: TERRY

OK. It looks like this is the collection of both my father and my uncle. I have duplicates of around 70 autographs, over 40 letters from presidents of fan clubs, 6 copies of "As You Like It" magazine (one w/ Brickhouse on cover) and about 50 newspaper and mag clippings from '53, '54, '55 era featuring the wrestlers including a couple with Jack Dempsey. I do remember some of these guys who were still around in the 70's, when I was a kid, but many of these names don't ring a bell. I have archived the whole collection now and can provide a list of names if anyone is interested to learn more and might be able to give me some advice on how to proceed offering this up to someone who collects this sort of thing. Many Thanks!
Dec 27, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Gorgeous George and the Beckers
by: Anonymous

I have an autograph of Gorgeous George in an old autograph book that belonged to my mother. Can anyone tell me what its worth?? Also, George and Bobby Becker?

Really appreciate any feedback,

Thanks,
Scarlett

_____

Answer: Gorgeous George, $50 and the Beckers, about 10 each.

Bill
Feb 04, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Autograph book
by: Anonymous

I received a book of wrestling autographs in a box of stuff I bought. I used to be a wrestling fan and know it contains wrestling stars from the 80s and 90s. I would assume the ones worth the most are the guys who are no longer with us, like Owen Hart and Junkyard Dog. But there are others like Hogan, Hart, etc. Any ideas on how much it's worth?
Jul 01, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstarstar 		Autographed WCW Monday Night Nitro T-shirt
by: Dogface

Good afternoon gentlemen. I was reading over your conversation & ya'll really seem to know what you're talking about so I have a question for ya'll. I have a t-shirt that is autographed by about two dozen superstars, Ric Flair, Arn Anderson, Sting, Lex Luger & Hulk Hogan just to name a few. I got it back in 1996 when Monday Night Nitro made its debut in Atlanta at the legendary Omni. Any thoughts on whether or not it has any real value?

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How?
Simply click here to return to Wrestling


Copyright 2009-2012 collecting-celebrity-autographs.com
All Rights Reserved
Trademarks Used on This Website Belong to Their Respective Owners.
Unauthorized Duplication or Publication of Materials Prohibited







Searching for a Particular Celebrity?
Search This Site





Subscribe in a reader